Her (2013)
Dir: Spike Jonze
“I think anybody who falls in love is a freak. It’s a crazy thing to do. It’s kind of like a form of socially acceptable insanity.”
Theordore Twombly (Joaquin Phoenix, ‘Gladiator’) is a lonely man who is going through a prolonged and reluctant divorce, working as a personal letter writer for other people, he puts complex emotions into words for strangers, but is unable to develop his own relationships. When he upgrades to a new operating system with advanced artificial intelligence called Samantha (the voice of Scarlett Johansson), he becomes drawn to her view of the world and the two become close… very close!
A similar idea to this was featured in an episode of ‘The Big Bang Theory’ when Raj fell in love with Siri, but here the idea of a lonely man who has been disappointed by human relationships and so becomes unusually close to his OS is fleshed out for a feature film length. Funnily enough, though high-concepts like this are often great in short form, then fall flat when stretched out, I didn’t feel that to be the case here. The slightly futuristic world that Theodore lives in is so familiar to our own, filmed in beautifully architectural parts of L.A. and Shanghai. All the technology, while not in every home right now, is available, so rather than viewers merely seeing things as a sci-fi futuristic scenario, the focus is kept on the interpersonal relationships that take place rather than the time or setting.
All other relationships shown in the film are troubled and flawed in some way, thus making his unusual one with Samantha seem a lot more logical, reasonable, and understandable. His estranged wife (Rooney Mara) is said to be in need of medication and was raised without praise from her parents, making her always in need of his approval. Theodore goes on a blind date with Amelia (Olivia Wilde) and they hit it off brilliantly over dinner, but this disintegrates instantly afterwards due to commitment issues and her calling him ‘creepy’ without much reason except possibly alcohol. His best friend Amy (Amy Adams) is married, and while they dated briefly in college remain good friends, yet her own marriage ends as her overbearing husband becomes a monk. Even a woman who Theodore randomly connects with online for some ‘flirtation’ is quickly shown to be certifiably crazy!
So, with all these human relationships being troubled as they are, dating an intelligent and witty OS with the undeniably sexy voice of Scarlett Johansson becomes an increasingly rational option in comparison. What makes it even more incredible is that he’s not alone, and so when he finally opens up to Amy about his new girlfriend being an OS, the revelation is met with “what’s it like” rather than, what are you doing?”
The whole film is beautifully shot, and filled with a great quality cast that put in a variety of performances as each of their roles show distinctive qualities. Amy Adams is far removed from the glamorous image as seen in ‘American Hustle’ or the confident and plucky Lois Lane in ‘Man of Steel’, here much more insecure and muted to fill the role of a best friend well. Joaquin Phoenix is well cast, his withdrawn and lonely Theodore wouldn’t attract any attention in the street or on the subway, but then when his relationship is flourishing, Phoenix wonderfully makes the same man come alive with enthusiasm and joy for life, the transformation is excellently conveyed and helps to negate the expected audience reactions to his romance as the viewer is uplifted along with him.
Then there’s Scarlett Johansson… or at least her voice! When filming, the voice of Samantha was provided by an on-set Samantha Morton (‘John Carter‘), who was later replaced. Johansson’s voice is distinctive, incredibly feminine, and conveys all the tones, nuances, and rasps that distinguish it from the clearly electronic Siri or any other attempts at a digital speech system. While deemed ineligible for most acting awards owing to not actually being on screen at all in the film, Scarlett Johansson did win the award for ‘Best Actress’ at the Rome film festival for the role, as well as other wins and nominations in other awards.
One of my favorite parts of Spike Jonze’s direction and the editing, is how in many scenes, Theodore’s mind goes elsewhere while doing something or talking to someone. This is shown in flashes and glimpses of memories that are loosely related to his present actions, but it’s a beautifully human thing to do, that we are often thinking about or remembering something else even when talking to somebody or engaged in a task. This wonderfully adds weight to the arguments that arise between Theodore and Samantha when he discovers that she’s often doing other things or talking to other people, even when talking to him, a facet of her ability to multitask as a consciousness without a body. It causes friction between them, yet may be one of the most compelling evidences of her developing sense of self.
A very believable sci-fi concept that is acted out very well, that could elicit any number of reactions from viewers depending on how much you go with or resist the way that this romance is presented as a relationship that’s as valid as any other.

Like this:
Like Loading...